Why Stewart's Ice Cream Is the Best

View All of our Ice Cream Flavors

We MOO (Make Our Own) for you

  • Local milk & cream
  • Quality ingredients
  • Just the right amount of air, inclusions, and swirl
  • Made with care by owners of the business

We control it all the way to you

  • No middleman
  • Quicker delivery
  • Perfect conditions – other brands get abused during delivery or in the freezer.

We ONLY sell to you in our shops

Brands sold in supermarkets:

  • Continuously cut corners and reduce quality to lower price.
  • Use cheater packs (smaller packaging that looks like a half gallon) vs. Stewart’s full half gallon.

We scoop in the shop

  • You can taste dozens of flavors before you buy!
  • Try them in a sundae, cone, shake, dish or just a sample.

Variety / choices

  • Ice Cream, super rich ice cream, gelato, light ice cream, sherbet.
  • Dozens of fun delicious flavors sold at the cone counter, in half gallons, pints, and hand packed pints!

The real reason Stewart’s ice cream is so delicious – we really like good ice cream and we hope you do too!

Join the Club!

With our new Scoop Club card, you can buy ANY 10 items from our ice cream counter and get your 11th one FREE. Single scoop cones, hand-packed pints, milkshakes, hot fudge sundaes… it’s all included! Use the same card at all of our Stewart’s Shops locations.

View All of our Ice Cream Flavors

hand holding strawberry ice cream cone

Cones

Select any flavor from our ice cream counter to be enjoyed on a tasty cone. Choose from our traditional sugar cone or upgrade to a waffle cone. As always, sprinkles are free to add on top!

girl pouring chocolate on make your own sundae

Make Your Own Sundaes

A Stewart’s Shops classic! First choose a scoop from our ice cream counter and decorate it with as many delicious toppings as you’d like. Choose from chocolate sauce, caramel sauce, marshmallow, pineapple, rainbow sprinkles, and more!

milkshakes cheers

Milkshakes

Pick from any of the delicious ice cream flavors at our ice cream counter and turn it into a milkshake! Made from fresh and local dairy.

root beer float

Floats and Ice Cream Sodas

Pick from any ice cream at our ice cream counter and any Stewart’s soda, for your own perfect dessert mix! Vanilla and orange soda? Cotton Candy with seltzer and strawberry syrup? Follow wherever your sweet tooth takes you!

banana split sundae

Banana Splits

Go for the classic Banana Split, chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla ice cream or make it your own! Design it your way, with any flavor or topping combination you can dream of.

partner handing customer hand packed pint

Hand Packed Pints

Want to take your favorite ice cream counter flavor home with you? Ask for a hand packed pint! Perfect for limited edition flavors that you want to stock up on.

brownie sundae

Brownie Sundaes

Enjoy our decadent brownies with two scoops of your favorite flavors from our ice cream counter, and toppings too!

hot fudge sundae

Hot Fudge Sundaes

Your favorite flavor topped with warm, gooey hot fudge. Don’t forget the whipped cream and cherry on top!

sherbet coolers on a picnic table

Sherbet Coolers

Stewart’s Coolers are made with rainbow sherbet, our fruit juice Refreshers, and a splash of half and half.

mixed berry and strawberry banana smoothies

Fruit Smoothies

A tasty non-dairy option, right at the ice cream counter. Enjoy mixed berry or strawberry banana.

Stewart's Shops